I think Canon's Eye Control AF is a gimmick, because it's still too hit-and-miss (and more miss than hit)

Illustration depicting a photographer using Canon's Eye Control AF
(Image credit: Canon)

Canon's Eye Control AF technology was first introduced way back in 1992 on the EOS 5, but it wasn't quite the party trick it promised to be and was phased out.

Fast-forward to 2021 and it was reintroduced in the Canon EOS R3, where it pretty much did what it said it would do, but there were plenty of caveats, like it not working effectively if ambient light conditions were constantly changing. Another proviso was spectacles (and potentially even contact lenses) impeding its proper functioning.

When I tested the Eye Control AF on the EOS R3 back in 2022, I found it was a lot of fun to use, but getting it calibrated while wearing glasses definitely caused me a few headaches. Two years later, at the launch of the Canon EOS R5 Mark II and EOS R1, the camera maker mentioned that improvements had been made and Eye Control AF should now be more accurate for people who wear glasses – like me.

I recently spent about three weeks with the R5 II and, sadly, could not get Eye Control AF calibrated. I tried in various conditions – with and without glasses (thank goodness for EVF diopters!) – and had no success. I even reset the camera twice… no joy. There was always a significant lag between my eye movement and the circular reticule during calibration, which meant I didn't get to try it out again.

Adding salt to my wounds was the fact that my colleagues were able to experience it when they got their hands on the EOS R1 at a media event. Tim Coleman at our sister site TechRadar was impressed, and Digital Camera World's very own James Artaius is a big fan of the technology too.

Me, not so much – I think it's gimmicky.

Animated clip depicting the UI for Canon's Eye Control AF

(Image credit: Canon)

Two AF systems is one too many

Now, don't get me wrong, I'm not calling it gimmicky because I couldn't make it work on the R5 II – I'm basing this on my experience with the R3. I just don't see the point of an additional layer of autofocus on a pro-level camera if it won't be useful all the time.

I use the word 'layer' as Eye Control AF is optional to use. As a photographer I am all for technology that makes my work simpler and faster – if just looking at a subject locks the focus point, dammit, I want to use it all the time to speed things up. But it really needs to work all the time. And this brings me to why it won't be useable consistently.

Eye Control AF is extremely dependent on external factors – while the distance between your eye and the EVF is important (which is why people who wear glasses might have trouble), it's even more finicky about ambient light.

Eye Control AF works based on a retina scan created when infrared light hits the back of the eye. When the ambient light conditions change, so does the eye itself to adjust. And even though you can save a few different calibrations based on various environmental settings, they're not going to be the same unless you work in a studio.

With the R3, I had more hits than misses, but I had more misses than hits with the R5 II – either way, there wasn't much consistency.

Illustration depicting a photographer using Canon's Eye Control AF

(Image credit: Canon)

Not only do I wear glasses, I usually have one eye closed when I peer through the viewfinder – which means the open eye is never going to be a consistent size, and that makes the calibrations for Eye Control AF that much harder. The only way around this is to keep both eyes open and, for someone set in her ways, that's not the most natural thing for me to do.

Fortunately, as I found out when testing the R3, the default AF reticule remains visible through the EVF at all times, which means cameras like the R5 II and R1 will still be able to capture a sharp, focused shot.

Moreover, autofocus speeds are so darn quick these days, I don't think even the human eye can keep up. Well, maybe it can, but that still begs the question: do we really need Eye Control AF?

For the headlines perhaps, but I think the technology still has a way to go before anyone can make Eye Control AF work the way it should.

Want to know more about Canon's 2024 releases? Read about what we think about Canon's in-camera AI-powered editing features and how they can affect your workflow. Or you can find out more about the best Canon cameras and the best Canon RF lenses.

TOPICS
Sharmishta Sarkar
Managing Editor (APAC)

Along with looking after they day-to-day functioning of Digital Camera World in Australia, Sharmishta is the Managing Editor (APAC) for TechRadar as well. Her passion for photography started when she was studying monkeys in the wilds of India and is entirely self-taught. That puts her in the unique position to understand what a beginner or enthusiast is looking for in a camera or lens, and writes to help those like her on their path to developing their skills or finding the best gear. While she experiments with quite a few genres of photography, her main area of interest is nature – wildlife, landscapes and macros.

Read more
Sigma fp L with EVF-11 accessory viewfinder
The lack of viewfinders on modern mirrorless cameras is short-sighted, and I wish optional EVFs were on offer
Canon camera top LCD showing Fv mode activated
Whaddya mean Canon invented a shooting mode that combines aperture and shutter priority? I reckon Fv mode should be talked about more!
Woman wearing a pair of white Ray-Ban Meta smart glasses
I'm sure cameras glasses will never be a thing, and here's why
Leica M with EVF mockup
The end of an era? Why an EVF in a Leica M feels like a mistake
Close-up of a person with long hair wearing Ray-Ban Meta glasses
Smart glasses will be really useful for photographers (but not for taking photos)
Canon PowerShot SX740 HS camera
My friend just bought a Canon PowerShot SX740 HS – proving that the camera industry is out of touch
Latest in Digital Cameras
Banner for a Bird Buddy bird feeder on a blue background
My favorite bird feeder camera is on sale in Amazon's super spring sale
Canon PowerShot V1
Canon’s first serious compact camera in years is finally here – but is the Canon PowerShot V1 just the start?
Insta360 X3 deal
My favourite beginner's 360-degree camera under $300: Insta360 X3 lowest price ever
Taylor swift, wearing her hair in pigtails with a cream colored sweater, standing at a microphone, with an Olympus OM-D E-M10 Mark IV next to her and the text "Price drop"
Want Taylor Swift's camera? Buy it today and get a FREE lens
OM System OM-1 camera deal
Holy cow! OM System OM-1 camera drops to its lowest price ever!
HFSTools
Easy-to-buy thermal camera deals go live for Amazon's Big Spring Sale
Latest in Features
Black and white image montage, three images showing scenes from the streets of Barcelona
“If you want to photograph a dynamic scene, you have to make do without a tripod”, I just love this cinematic night shoot!
Jacob Watson-Howland's image of a snowdrop in low-light, captured with a slow shutter speed to create a painterly abstract effect
“I didn’t bring a tripod. Big mistake.” Second attempt at low-light plant portrait lands young photographer prestigious award
A monochromatic image, showing a girl that looks through a door or window with an obscure view
These are the winners from Digital Photographer's captivating portraits contest
Fujifilm X-T5 with lens attached
If the Fujifilm X-T6 launches with this one feature, I’m going to be the first in line
Meta AI suggesting comments for Instagram image
Instagram is testing AI that analyzes photos and generates comments… but isn't that the opposite of solving the bot problem?
Kalum Carter
Can you actually tell the difference between images taken on the Fujifilm X100F and GFX 50S II?