Opinion: Automatic camera settings kill creativity and stop you building skills

Canon
Manually created lighting, specific choice of rock and toad, precise placement of focus, makes this more than a simple automatic snapshot (Image credit: Brian Worley)

Automation has come to many things in life, and sometimes it’s helpful, but not always. Having started taking photos years ago with an all manual film camera I recall the intense need to learn much about photography to get a top photo. That knowledge does help me today to decide when to make use of the helpful auto, and when to rely on my own skills. 

Canon EOS cameras introduced many photographers to sharper photos thanks to autofocus. Often these days I hear photographers questioning why their camera is not able to focus on a particular subject. I have to think, would the photographer be able to achieve the desired result without AF? Frequently the answer is no, and that’s not a bad thing, it demonstrates how far the technology has come in the last thirty years.

But knowing when the subject will be a challenge for AF is when I can apply whatever skill I have to aid the AF to get it right. If you don’t recognize the difficult-to-focus subject, then a swooping bird of prey is no different from a painting on a wall. Your expectation is that the camera should cope itself.

What about auto exposure?

Now consider auto exposure; that joyous way to ensure that almost all our photos turn out with the right exposure. A wise photographer once told me there was no right exposure, only the exposure that I thought was right. There’s surely an exposure where the highlights and shadows are captured correctly. But technically correct is hardly pushing the bounds of creativity. Results can be more interesting with technically incorrect exposures.

Looking through my camera there’s auto white balance, auto lighting optimizer, automatic flash exposure, automatic lens correction, auto ISO, AF point auto switching, automatic face tracking, and many more. All this automation is good for making quality record shots of everyday photo situations. Sometimes you need to be in control and harness the technology, make it do your bidding and be creative.

Automatic is a great way to start out, but you need to bring your own creative flair to photos (Image credit: Brian Worley)
PhotoPlus: The Canon Magazine

PhotoPlus: The Canon Magazine is the world's only monthly newsstand title that's 100% devoted to Canon, so you can be sure the magazine is completely relevant to your system. Every issue comes with downloadable video tutorials too. 


You might also like the best Canon lenses and the Canon EOS R10 review.

Brian Worley

Brian is a freelance photographer and photo tutor, based in Oxfordshire. He has unrivaled EOS DSLR knowledge, after working for Canon for over 15 years, and is on hand to answer all the EOS and photographic queries in Canon-centric magazine PhotoPlus.

Read more
Pixel 9 series imaging tools
AI-powered cameras mean I don’t know what photography is anymore
Man twiddling his mustache
"Photographers must be problem solvers, not robots" reckons Paul Wilkinson
Kalum Carter
I'd take character over precision any day! Why vintage lenses and imperfection matter more than ever
The exposure triangle with pictogram examples of the effects aperture, shutter speed and ISO have on photographs
This is how I learned the exposure triangle and how I use it to shoot in manual mode
Canon camera top LCD showing Fv mode activated
Whaddya mean Canon invented a shooting mode that combines aperture and shutter priority? I reckon Fv mode should be talked about more!
Portrait of woman with blonde hair and wearing a red jacket in front of a blurred background of red, green and gold bokeh, next to an inset roundel of a finger pointing to the AF-ON button on a Sony camera
I’m a photography expert, and I hated back-button focus at first; here’s why I now LOVE using it …
Latest in Photo Technique
Backing up data is so annoying that most would rather…scrub toilets!
A screenshot of the Adobe Stock Customize tool
Adobe Stock now enables you to mass-edit with AI – but is it a nail in the coffin for stock photography, or another way for creators to earn money?
AIarty Image Matting
Cut the chaos: AI-powered background removal + free giveaway for photographers!
Neurapix before and after of smiling bride holding bouquet of flowers
“Neurapix reduced my editing time by 50%” – why this AI Lightroom plug-in is taking wedding photography by storm
Image of a red motorbike split into two halves, the first half exhibits camera shake and the second half is sharp
Slow shutter speeds have created a camera shake crisis, and I reckon ISO and Instagram are largely to blame…
Front cover photograph of the Ultimate Photography Ideas Book, which contains more than 60 photo projects covering a wide range of genres, published by Ilex Press and on sale now
Digital Camera World photo projects book is on sale now!
Latest in Tutorials
Total lunar eclipse
How I’ll photograph the blood moon total lunar eclipse tonight, one of the best astrophotography events of the year
Wildlife portrait of a gannet in front of a clean green background
10 tips for wildlife photography from birds in flight to insect close-ups
Mountain valley during sunrise. Natural summer landscape
9 landscape photography tips I think every photographer should know
Bride and groom hold hands aloft backlit against the sun on their wedding day
Want to be a wedding photographer? Here are my 11 tips that will help you get there the RIGHT way
Colourful trees frame a small river, photographed with a long exposure
I love to shoot long exposures in the rain – here’s why I head to the woods!
What is ISO in photography?